Suze Orman Says 3%, Bill Bengen Says 4.7%–Who’s Right on Sustainable Withdrawal Rates?

David McKnight compares the approach of some of the biggest names in personal finance: Suze Orman, and William “Bill” Bengen (the man who invented the 4% Rule).

In a recent interview covered by MSN, Suze Orman declared flat out that the 4% Rule is dead since markets are volatile, interest rates fluctuate, and people are living longer.

David shares the “origin story” of how the 4% Rule came to be – and its creator Bill Bengen.

Interviewed by MSN, Bengen updated his research and concluded that, based on current data, a 4.7% withdrawal rate is now sustainable.

David compares Orman’s views on the 4% Rule with those of Bengen.

As explained by David, when you purchase a guaranteed lifetime income annuity, you’re transferring a portion of your retirement savings to an insurance company in exchange for a guaranteed paycheck for life.

Remember: not all annuities are created equal – that’s why you need to understand fees, credit ratings, inflation writers and surrender periods.

Mentioned in this episode:

David’s new book, available now for pre-order: The Secret Order of Millionaires

David’s national bestselling book: The Guru Gap: How America’s Financial Gurus Are Leading You Astray, and How to Get Back on Track

Tax-Free Income for Life: A Step-by-Step Plan for a Secure Retirement by David McKnight

DavidMcKnight.com

DavidMcKnightBooks.com

PowerOfZero.com (free video series)

@mcknightandco on Twitter

@davidcmcknight on Instagram

David McKnight on YouTube

Get David’s Tax-free Tool Kit at taxfreetoolkit.com

Suze Orman

William Bengen

Share the Post:

Schedule your one-on-one strategy session today

SCHEDULE STRATEGY SESSION

How Behavioral Biases Influence Your Financial Choices

When making financial decisions, logic and rational analysis should ideally guide the way. However, human psychology often plays an unexpected role in how people manage their investments, savings, and retirement plans. Behavioral biases in financial decision-making can lead to choices that may not align with long-term goals. Understanding these biases can help you take a more strategic approach to your financial future.

How to Avoid the Biggest Investment Mistakes Retirees Make

Retirement investing requires a different approach than wealth accumulation. The transition from growing assets to withdrawing income introduces new risks and potential pitfalls. Many retirees make mistakes that can impact their financial stability, often without realizing it until it’s too late. By understanding how to avoid the biggest investment mistakes retirees make, you can develop a retirement strategy that balances income, risk, and longevity.

The Role of Insurance in a Comprehensive Retirement Plan

A well-structured retirement plan isn’t just about savings and investments—it also includes insurance to help manage risks that could disrupt your financial security. While many focus on growing their retirement accounts, fewer consider how insurance can protect their assets and provide financial stability in unexpected situations. Understanding the role of insurance in a comprehensive retirement plan can help you build a strategy that not only grows your wealth but also safeguards it against potential risks.

Why Investing for Retirement is Different from Accumulation Investing

During your working years, your investment strategy focuses on accumulating assets. You contribute to retirement accounts, invest in growth-oriented assets, and rely on time to build wealth. However, once you transition into retirement, your approach must change. Instead of accumulating wealth, the focus shifts to preserving assets and generating income that can last throughout your lifetime. Understanding why investing for retirement is different from accumulation investing can help you make informed financial decisions as you approach this critical transition.

Balancing Growth and Stability in Your Retirement Portfolio

Retirement planning is about more than just accumulating assets—it’s about managing those assets in a way that provides both growth and stability. While investing in higher-growth assets can help sustain long-term financial needs, excessive risk could lead to losses that are difficult to recover from later in life. Balancing growth and stability in your retirement portfolio requires a strategic approach that adapts to market conditions, inflation, and evolving financial goals. The right mix of investments can help you build a resilient retirement plan that provides income, mitigates risks, and maintains purchasing power over time.

Retirement Risks No One Warned You About

Many people focus on saving enough money for retirement, but few consider the risks that could derail their financial plans. While market downturns and inflation are well-known concerns, other risks—like tax increases, healthcare costs, and longevity—can have an equally significant impact. Understanding retirement risks can help you create a more resilient financial strategy, ensuring that your assets last throughout your lifetime.